Replace the word Islam with the word Hindutva,replace the word Pakistan with Hindustan,replace the sea of green flags with saffron ones and you have BJP's nightmare vision of an ideal India.Everywhere there were Pakistani flags,everywhere the cry,"Pakistan se rishta kya?La ilaha illa llah".What is our bond with Pakistan?There is no God but Allah."Azadi ka matlab kya? La ilaha illa llah".What does Freedom mean? There is no God but Allah.For somebody like myself,who is not muslim,that interpretation of freedom is hard – if not impossible – to understand.I asked a young woman whether freedom for Kashmir would not mean less freedom for her,as a woman.She shrugged and said,"What kind of freedom do we have now?The freedom to be raped by Indian soldiers?"Her reply silenced me.It's impossible to even doubt or ignore the deep Islamic uprising in the valley when one stands in the TRC grounds and sees the sea of green flags swarming in front of you.
As the crowd swelled and great number of supporters join in,one can stand there quietly and listen to the slogans,often rhetoric which clarify things and give us a deeper understanding.Here are some…………"Kashmir Ki Mandi! Rawalpindi!"(Kashmir's market-place – Rawalpindi), another was "Khooni Lakir Tod Do,Aar Par Jod Do"(Break The Blood-Soaked Line Of Control,let Kashmir be united again).There were plenty of insults and humiliation for India: "Ay jabiron ay zalimon,Kashmir hamara chhod do"(Oh oppressors,Oh wicked ones,get out of our Kashmir). "Jis Kashmir ko khoon se seencha,who Kashmir hamara hai" (The Kashmir we have irrigated with our blood,that Kashmir is ours!). But the slogan which can cut through any Indian like a knife was this one: "Nanga bhooka Hindustan,jaan se pyaara Pakistan".(Naked,starving India,More precious than life itself – Pakistan). Why is it so galling,so painful to listen to this?Maybe of three main reasons: Firstly,we know that part of the slogan is embarrassing and unadorned truth about India,which is an emerging superpower.Secondly,the Indians,who are not nanga or bhooka have been complicit in the complex and historical ways with the cruel cultural and economic systems which makes the whole system so unequal.And Thirdly,because it was painful to listen to people who have suffered so much themselves,mock others who suffer in different ways,but no less intensely,under the same oppressor.In that slogan I saw the seeds of how easily victims can become perpetrators.